Home » News » How can you stop accidental managers from becoming organisational risks

How can you stop accidental managers from becoming organisational risks

Accidental managers are a business risk, not a personal development issue.

There is a moment in almost every organisation where a brilliant technical performer gets promoted and everyone breathes a sigh of relief: “Great, we’ve filled the vacancy.” Then, a few months later, the same organisation quietly starts paying the costs of that decision. Missed targets, grievances, avoidable absences, disengagement, and the slow drip of good people leaving.

This is not about blaming new managers. It is about acknowledging something we rarely say out loud: people management is a profession in its own right, and most organisations still treat it as an “add-on”.

The Chartered Management Institute (CMI) has been warning about the scale of the issue for years. Their research with YouGov found that 82% of people entering management roles have not had any formal management and leadership training, the classic “accidental manager” problem. And the human impact is not abstract either. One in three people said they had left a job because of a negative work culture, and half of those with an ineffective boss planned to quit within the next year. 

Now add a policy shock. The government has confirmed it will withdraw levy funding from 16 apprenticeship standards from September 2026, with start limits applying during the notice period. This includes popular management standards such as the Level 3 Team Leader and Level 5 Operations/Departmental Manager. Even if your organisation was not using those routes, the broader signal is clear with the “easy button” for funded management training is disappearing, just as operational complexity is rising.

So what should employers do?

First, reframe management development from “nice to have” to “risk management”. If half the people with ineffective bosses are thinking about leaving, management quality is a retention strategy (or a retention risk) whether you label it that way or not.  And if one in three people are willing to walk away from a toxic culture, it is naïve to not realise you’re your organisational culture are the things your managers permit, reward and role‑model. 

Second, define the minimum capability you expect from anyone who manages people in your organisation. In practice, that is a short, teachable toolkit: how to set expectations and give feedback; how to coach performance rather than “micromanage it”; how to lead inclusive teams; how to spot early warning signs of burnout; how to handle conflict before it escalates; and how to make decisions using evidence rather than hunches. When those basics are inconsistent, every other initiative your organisation runs (values, engagement, Equality Diversity and Inclusion, wellbeing, productivity) becomes harder than it needs to be.

Third, give managers development that respects reality. Most managers do not need inspiration, they need practical skills, applied quickly, with coaching support to make the new habits stick. That is why delivery design matters.

At Activate Business School our management programmes are built for application. They blend online learning with professional coaching and cover applied skills such as communication, managing budgets, performance coaching and project and risk management. We also recognise the need for leaders to be data savvy and have a certain level of digital competencies, which is why we have also data analytics, cyber security and AI into our repertoire of skillsets we look to hone and develop. Our programmes are designed to be delivered in open cohorts or bespoke formats, which helps managers learn from peers facing similar pressures while also applying learning directly to their own context. 

Finally, remember who feels the consequences first: your early career employees. The CMI has argued that reducing funding for management training makes it harder to support young workers, because their experience of work is shaped day-to-day by the managers they meet. If policy is trying to refocus apprenticeships towards younger entrants, then organisations must ensure their managers are equipped to nurture that talent when it arrives.

Accidental managers are not a quirky rite of passage. They are a predictable failure mode with an equally predictable fix: invest in management development early, make it practical, and treat it as a core part of your operational model.

Scroll to Top
Progression routes

What happens next? Most people stay on with the employer they train with, but there are plenty of options! You may decide to study a higher-level apprenticeship, return to academic studies, or work full time. We will support you whatever you decide!

The apprenticeship programme

You will have access to a range of support and advice we have on offer. This includes support from Advice and Admissions, Learning Support and Student Support.

You can access all facilities at Activate Learning Colleges and reap benefits, such as student discount. However, you may not be entitled to certain funding and travel bursaries as apprenticeships are paid positions.

How much will I earn?

The amount you’ll earn will vary depending on the nature of your role, sector and business you are working with.

The minimum hourly rate for an apprentice is £8.00, however most apprentices are paid more than this. If you are over 19 and have completed one year, you will be paid national minimum wage. 

You will also be entitled to the same conditions as all other employees in a business, including paid holiday, sick pay and pensions (where requirements are met).

What can I expect from my apprenticeship?

You must be at least 16 years old when you start an apprenticeship.

There are 3 types of apprenticeships depending on your requirements and previous qualifications: day release, work-based and block-release.

Your apprenticeship programme may be assessed with:

  • Practical assessments/exams
  • A portfolio of evidence
  • Interviews and presentations
  • Final assessments
  • On and off the job training

You will have a performance coach visit your workplace every eight weeks as well as an inhouse mentor throughout your apprenticeship.

An apprenticeship typically lasts 24 months, but can vary between 12 months to 5 years.